If the top from your vehicle has let you down and you’re looking for the best replacement soft top for Jeep Wrangler JK, you’ve discovered the perfect article.
A quality soft top will protect your Jeep from various weather conditions while also enhancing its appearance.
Give your Jeep a fresh look and maintain its quality by simply choosing the right cover. Finding the perfect brand is not easy, so here is a top that will make your life easier.
The Comparison Table of Jeep Wrangler JK Replacement Soft Top For (2022 Updated)
How To Choose the Soft Top For Jeep JK
Before going through all the amazing brands and models that are on the market, it’s important to understand what you’re looking for in the best soft top for Jeep Wrangler JK 2/4 door. So, here is a list to help you organize your ideas.
01. Resistant Fabric
First of all, the best soft top is created from the best materials. A quality fabric should incorporate elastic properties that allow it to stretch or contract during the installation process.
This will make your life easier and ensure that the fabric attaches properly.
Next, check if the top can maintain its form in all weather conditions. It shouldn’t sag due to water accumulation and it shouldn’t alter its form in hot temperatures.
Some excellent materials are sailcloth and polyester-coated vinyl. Also, the twill soft top is one of the best options.
Quieter and better insulated, it’s superior to the black. However, it’s more difficult to clean.
02. Marine-Grade Stitching
Next, you should check the type of stitching found in the soft top. To be more precise, the only specification you will find about this is “marine-grade stitching .”
If you read these words, count them like a pro for the product, as this stitching ensures that you won’t encounter leaking problems with your top.
03. Fold-Back Sunroof Feature
This function is especially useful for Jeep passionates who enjoy an outdoor experience. During hot summer days, even the best quality soft top can retain some heat.
So, the best alternative that’s out there is to come up with an open-air driving experience by introducing a fold-back sunroof feature.
The sunroof option can be easily accessed by releasing the header channel. Moreover, you can convert it back to full coverage in some simple steps.
If the weather happens to be against you, a sudden storm won’t be a cause of stress, as you can switch between the open-air and full coverage options in no time.
If you’re not experienced in doing research for car parts & accessories, this is a tip you should never forget.
Car accessories, as well as necessary items, like a soft top, are fitted for different models of vehicles.
There are a large variety of brands that create soft tops, so you’ll surely find one that is perfectly compatible with your Jeep Wrangler JK, but make sure that this is the first aspect you check.
05. Removable, Tinted Windows
Removable and replaceable windows are also an important aspect to consider when searching for the best replacement soft top for Jeep Wrangler JK.
First of all, the kit should come with both side and rear windows. Then, you should look for clear windows that ensure the best visibility, as safety is also our priority.
Removable features also offer a unique open-air experience. Lastly, you’ll probably find that tinted windows can also be purchased.
They are either included or listed as extra and usually come with an 18% or 31% tint. The tint has multiple roles, enhancing both the aspect and the functionality of the vehicle.
It gives you Jeep Wrangler a unique, modern look, and it helps to keep the interior of the car cooler in hot weather, maintaining your comfort.
06. Installation Systems
Just as the fabric can differ in different soft tops, the installation process can also be easy or complex and it can involve different systems.
Some examples are bow arrangements, a belt-rail system, and YKK scoop-counted zippers. The average installation time is 3-5 hours, and it may require one or two persons.
Look for soft tops that come with step-by-step instructions, as this truly helps anyone who doesn’t have experience in the field.
Moreover, some tops come with their own hardware, while other kits are based on the original factory hardware. This aspect can be quite tricky, so don’t forget to put it on the list.
07. Aspect and Customization
Finally, everyone appreciates a good-looking top. Some models offer unique features, like a tonneau-style rear cover or tinted windows that can give your Jeep and fresh and modern aspect.
You can also add door skins and other amazing extra features, so look for tops that are compatible with this level of customization.
What is The Top Quality Replacement Soft Top For Jeep JK?
If you put together all the best features for a soft top, you’ll get Bestop 54823-17. Over the years, this brand has truly shown its benefits, gaining the trust of customers all around the world.
Specialized in making car tops, Bestop provides both quality and impressive aesthetics in its many available models.
Keep in mind that 54823-17 is the first choice for 2007-2018 Jeeps. Next in line, the 79841-17 model is the perfect option for a 1997-2006 Jeep Wrangler JK.
Flexible and resistant, the soft top will prevent the deterioration of your car and keep it safe, even in bad weather.
Is Bestop Brand Worth as Soft Top For Jeep Wrangler 4-Door/2-Door?
The premium materials, as well as the smart design of the 54823-17 model, make it the best for a jeep wrangler 4 door.
It’s accessible, incorporating a tailgate bar that spares you the trouble of opening the rear window, and it offers a wrinkle-resistant fabric that doesn’t contain PCVs. No wonder there are no bad reviews for this brand.
Even more, Bestop 54823-17 offers impressive features, like the fold-back sunroof that transforms your ride into an open-air adventure any time you wish. What more can you ask for?
14 Best Replacement Soft Top For Jeep Wrangler JK on The Market
01. BESTOP 54823-17
- Compatible with 2007-2018 Jeep Wrangler
- Fold-back sunroof
- Removable tinted vinyl windows
- YKK scoop counted zippers
- Patented door surrounds
- No wrinkles and minimum water puddling
Bestop 54823-17 gets first place on the top for the best soft top for 4-door jeep wrangler and with good reasons.
Not only is this brand one of the most trusted top producers for Jeep Wrangler, but it’s also one of the most qualitative ones, offering professionalism and efficiency.
The first benefit you’ll notice about this model is the premium material. Bestop uses a triple-layer fabric for vehicles 2013-2018 and exclusive Top Arch bar support for this fabric.
This small feature works like a miracle, as it minimizes both wrinkles and water accumulation, offering a comfortable experience at any time.
The high-quality material maintains its properties and form during extreme temperatures and comes with UV inhibitors to protect you and your passengers.
When it comes to its design, Bestop 54823-17 doesn’t disappoint either.
The soft top for Jeep Wrangler JK comes with a tailgate bar that allows you to access the tailgate without any stress and the polymer hardware for the installation is thermoplastic and efficient.
The soft top is overall more flexible than a regular one, with a smoother and softer feel and superior performance.
Finally, the feature that impresses any driver is the fold-back rooftop. A road trip can instantly transform into an open-air driving experience, making all your fantasies come true.
Even more, the tinted windows can also be easily removed, as they come with scoop-counted zippers for easy accessibility.
- Durable material
- Incredible interior aspect
- Premium quality
- Complex installation
02. BESTOP 79841-17
- YKK scoop-counted zippers
- Superior cold weather performance
- Belt-rail system
- Heat-sealed vinyl windows
- Optional door skins can be added
So close to first place, Bestop 79841-17 is another smart and useful creation, incorporating different features at the same quality as the previous model.
It has the classic Bestop specifications, offering YKK scoop-counted zippers for easier access and a triple-layered twill material that protects your Jeep Wrangler JK, so you can travel without any worries.
When searching for the best soft top, it’s a must to check its compatibility.
79841-17 is the perfect model for the 2007-2017 Jeep Wranglers, specially designed for a snug fit and an easy installation process.
However, in case you don’t have the skills of a professional mechanic, it’s always a good idea to call for help. What’s great about this model is its superior cold-weather performance.
With durable and thick material, as well as DOT-approved vinyl windows, even the winter’s cold can’t defeat this soft top.
Moreover, it comes with both rear and side windows that can be attached with a simple, smart system.
The Belt-Rail system offers the perfect fit, transforming the installation part into a pleasurable experience. The tint will even provide a cooler interior while driving in hot temperatures.
Moreover, to ensure not only your safety but also your comfort, the fabric can considerably reduce outside noise, offering proper insulation.
On top of all these, the model is highly customizable. Extra features can be added easily, including 18% tinted windows and door skins that will create an impressive look.
- Perfect fit for Jeep Wrangler JK
- Modern aspect
- Easy installation
- Side windows may have waves
03. BESTOP 5472235
- Fitted for 2007-2018 Jeep Wrangler
- Full soft top kit
- Quick-release bow knuckles
- Available in multiple colors
- 18% tinted windows for cooler interior
Let’s start with the part that makes this product one of the best soft tops for 2 door Jeep Wrangler. Bestop 5472235 is the only soft-top full kit that comes with available hardware for your JK.
As its name states, it truly is a supertop. The patented door surrounds make installation way easier, providing an exact fit on the vehicle.
Also, keep in mind that the product is compatible with the 2007- 2018 models. This is a great advantage, as the soft top is fitted for a large range of vehicles and can be easily transferred.
However, when you’re in a hurry, it can be easy to overlook even important aspects, so make sure that the first thing you check is always compatibility.
Even more, the brand added quick-release bow knuckles, so you can adjust the bow system to obtain the perfect fabric flexibility and aspect.
The high-quality material is ensured to maintain its shape on both winter and summer trips and it’s designed to protect from UV rays that can harm your skin tissue on hot days.
This model contains features you didn’t even know you needed. From safety measures to advanced functions that maintain the comfort of your passengers, Bestop thought of everything. All that’s left for you to do is install and enjoy the item.
- It’s a great option for winter
- Comes with instructions
- The top is quiet while driving
- Uncomfortable light reflection if the top is folded
04. BESTOP TREKTOP 54923-35
- Fully retractable
- Slant black
- Patented sun rider panel
- Rear panel for easy setup
- Fitted for Jeep Wrangler JK 2007-2018
- Zipperless windows
Bestop did it again with this Fully retractable trecktop.
This is the only fully convertible fast black soft top available out there, and this aspect surely makes it worth it to a position in the top for the best replacement soft tops for Jeep Wrangler JK.
The kit comes with soft fabric, as well as rear and side windows, all the needed hardware, and even a tailgate bar.
Providing all the conditions, the brand makes sure that the setup is as easy as it can be.
However, don’t expect a 15 minutes job. Any top installation requires around 3 hours, great instructions, and skilled hands.
Next, let’s talk about the open-air ride experience this soft top can offer. All users have been amazed by its fast convertibility.
Combining a durable fabric with flexible materials, Bestop managed to create a fully retractable top. You can enjoy the sunny weather, then change your Jeep into a fully covered vehicle in no time.
There’s no need to worry about spontaneous rain anymore. You can drive comfortably and be protected at the same time.
- Completely seals from rain
- Fast convertibility
- Black diamond fabric
- Can be noisy
05. SMITTYBILT 9075235
- Marine-grade vinyl
- Sealed seams
- Comes with door surrounds
- 1-inch fabric flexibility
- Compatible with Jeep JK 2-door
Smittybilt offers a great soft top replacement alternative. Even though it’s not as popular as Bestop, this brand provides protection while also enhancing the vehicle’s aspect.
The top fits 2006-2018 Jeep Wrangler JK, so compatibility shouldn’t be an issue in this case.
The model comes with tinted side windows that add a modern touch and keep the interior cooler during a hot day.
At the same time, the black diamond fabric prevents leaks and keeps you safe from both storms and blinding sun.
Moreover, this soft top considerably improves night vision while driving, creating more visibility and a clearer vision than the original models.
The top is only fitted for Jeep Wrangler JK 2-door, so make sure to check all specifications before considering it.
Also, you’ll need to use the original hardware during the installation process, as the kit doesn’t include its own.
When it comes to the setup, the brand offers universal instructions for a large variety of vehicles and climate conditions.
The suggested installation temperature is 70 degrees Fahrenheit. If any temperature change occurs, the flexible fabric is designed to stretch or contract more than an inch and adapt to the conditions.
Soon after the material is relaxed, any wrinkles will disappear and you’ll have the final result.
- Thin yet durable materials
- Offers clear visibility at night
- The middle flap can be hard to install
06. BESTOP 56853-35
- Zipperless technology
- OE-style door surrounds
- Fast and easy opening
- Sunrider panel with mesh pockets
- Integrated header
- 2 fabric options are available
This model has all the qualities of the best soft top for the Jeep Wrangler 4 door.
Besides its incredible features, the top even comes in 2 options regarding the fabric and 7 different colors, so you’ll surely find the perfect option for your Jeep in terms of aesthetics.
With one replacement, any vehicle will get a fresh, modern look that will instantly impress.
Besides the patented factory door surrounds, tinted windows, and tailgate bar, the top comes with creative features to enhance your comfort and make your day better.
The brand included a Sunrider panel with mesh and zipper pockets that can stock small items.
In addition to this, an integrated header, as well as removable windows offer, make this top unique and worthy of your attention. A variety of customizable, optional features are also available.
From different window configurations to interesting door kits, Bestop allows you to create the perfect aspect for your Jeep Wrangler.
Choose between heavy-duty, black diamond fabric and premium twill, and enjoy their durability, as well as smart design.
- Great customer service
- All-seasons functionality
- Zipper pockets
- The sunrise pivot bracket may not line up
- Water accumulation
07. BESTOP PAVEMENT ENDS 51204-35
- Black Diamond
- Kit includes upper door skins
- Fade-resistant fabric
- Waterproof windows
Pavement Ends is an accessories and tops line created by Bestop.
Wallet-friendly and qualitative, this line delivers exactly what you asked for: a durable and aesthetic soft top to keep your vehicle protected at all times.
The line has more than 25 years of experience in designing tops fitted for Jeep JK, gaining a place on our list for the best soft tops for Jeep Wrangler 2 door.
Designed as a replacement soft top, 51204-35 is a model that requires your original bows, tailgate bar, and frames.
However, it offers waterproof, flexible fabric, with rear and side windows and even upper door skins.
Available in multiple fabrics and colors, with optional extra features for a comfortable experience, this model is surely worth considering.
No leaks, no buffering, and no annoying sounds while driving at high speeds!The windows are sealed to prevent the access of both heat and liquids.
They are made of DOT-approved vinyl and ensure comfortable driving conditions in any weather.
You are free to choose clear or 28-millimeters thick windows or 18% tinted ones, depending on the available models.
For Wrangler, there are 4 main choices: soft tops fitted for 1988-1995, 1997-2006, 2007-2009, and 2010-2017 vehicles.
- Thick fabric
- New weatherstripping foam included
- No flapping or buffering while driving
- Window zippers need improvement
08. SIERRA AUTO TOPS & SEATS 10-40-JK31013-22
- Fitted for Jeep Wrangler 2010-2018
- Sailcloth vinyl
- No new hardware is needed
- Over-sized zippers
- Factory-spec velcro
- Direct soft top replacement
Sierra auto tops & seats are an original alternative to the classic Bestop.
Providing new fabric colors and interesting models, the brand ensures not only the safety of your Jeep’s interior but also its aspect. What sets this item apart is the step-by-step, easy installation process.
Incorporating a stretchy but resistant fabric for a fast setup, as well as detailed instructions, the brand makes sure you’ll finish the job quickly and enjoy the results of your work.
However, reserve about 3-4 hours for this process, as things don’t always go as planned when it comes to mechanics.
Despite its elastic properties during the installation part, after it’s all done, the fabric maintains its shape during all temperatures, creating a strong cover for your vehicle. It works just like an OEM top, but it lasts longer!
- Step by step installation instructions
- Great quality
- Tinted rear windows available
- Bars and hinges are not included
09. RUGGED RIDGE 13737.45
- Thick 30 mil windows
- Heavy-duty pull areas
- Premium fabric & marine-grade thread
- Vinyl coated polyester
- An additional layer of fabric
To form an opinion about any brand, you need to read reviews, and here is an amazing one.
Rugged Ridge truly deserves to be considered one of the best replacement soft tops for Jeep Wrangler JK.
Despite the minor flaws that are encountered in any product, this model survived a Cat 5 hurricane with barely any leaks. The fabric quality is substantially better than the quality of your original one.
The side windows are slightly overlapped by the doors’ rubber gasket, which can be considered a downside, but it depends on the driver.
Besides its many functional benefits, this soft top also looks amazing, improving the aspect of any vehicle.
For a fully protected interior, the fabric is covered in an additional layer that reduces wind noise while driving. Moreover, it is UV treated and created to match the aspect of your original equipment.
Rugged Ridge uses mainly vinyl-coated polyester in multiple colors. In this case, the 13737.45 model is available in Black diamond, an option that fits almost every existing Jeep out there.
Give your Wrangler a much-needed makeover and try for yourself this amazing soft top.
- Can survive a Cat 5 hurricane
- Better fabric than OEM
- Easy installation
- The rear window zipper is not durable
10. SIERRA OFFROAD 10-40-JK21015-21
- Self-correcting zippers
- Heat-sealed seams
- Compatible with 2010-2018 Jeep Wrangler
- Requires original hardware & top frame
- Premium materials
Here is another great replacement option for Jeep Wrangler 4 door.
Keep in mind that you’ll need the original hardware for a proper installation and that the model is only compatible with 2010-2018 Jeeps.
A black sailcloth vinyl offers this soft top an incredible aspect, while the marine grade stitching resists fading and keeps away leaks.
Moreover, to further protect your vehicle from unwanted water accumulation and water exposure, all seams are fully sealed.
The top is a direct fitment for the factory hardware and to make installation even easier, the elastic properties of its materials allow it to stretch and contract as you need.
The header requires lots of screws, but don’t give up easily, as it’s all worth it!
Another great feature of this soft top is its capacity to retain heat in cold weather and keep the interior of your vehicle cold during a hot day of summer.
Including special thermic properties, Sierra Offroad ensures not only your protection but also your comfort.
- It doesn’t leak
- Holds the heat in cold weather
- Makes less noise than the original top
- It flaps in the wind
11. BESTOP 56823-35
- No bows or frames involved
- Fold back sunroof feature
- Extended surface heat sealing
- Compatible with 2007-2017 Jeep Wrangler JK
- Fabrics tuck into the doors’ surrounding channel
- Tension straps
When it comes to new generation tops & accessories, Bestop always has your back. Always one step ahead, the brand created a new soft model that requires no bows and no frames to install.
Incorporating the best features and newest designs, 56823-35 will surely catch your eye.There are some impressive, upgraded features available for this soft top.
Besides a Quick release bow knuckles and a top arch bar system, the brand even added polymer door surrounds that match the style of your original Jeep Wrangler JK.
There’s no surprise when customers all over the world declare Bestop’s products the best soft top for Jeep Wrangler JK 2/4 door.
Another great addition is the tensioning strap. Pulling on the tension bar and attached to the back of the tub, this bar keeps the fabric wrinkle-free and provides the best aspect, as well as great weather adaptation.
And now that we mentioned weather conditions, the sunroof option is the next aspect that must be mentioned. Just like other Bestop soft tops, this model comes with the option of an open-air ride.
Simply release the header channel and enjoy a sunny day to its fullest. On the other hand, on a rainy day, the aluminum top arch bar is there for your protection.
This bar keeps puddling to a minimum and maintains the fabric’s shape so it can do its job properly.
- Sporty fastback look
- Panels can be reinstalled easily
- Excellent customer service
- Problems with back flapping
12. RAMPAGE PRODUCTS 990135
- Closed-cargo design
- Unique tonneau feature
- The front panel can be folded
- 30 oz premium sailcloth
- Full kit with hardware & door surrounds
Rampage comes back with another great soft top for your JK. Known as one of the best replacement soft tops for Jeep Wrangler, the brand came up with a new, unique design.
Including a tonneau-style rear cover, it changed the old aesthetics of a classic top, giving any rig the look of a pickup.
Even more, the design adds the advantages of a closed cab that perfectly fits the original roll bar.
The Trailview’s fabric is a premium, waterproof sailcloth that prevents wind noise and water accumulation, keeping leaks away from the gorgeous interior of your Jeep.
The best soft top involves the best materials but also the best construction. In this area, the brand makes sure that stitching is performed by professionals, so only quality products will arrive at your door.
The necessary items including a tailgate bar, door surrounds, and even fold-back hardware comes with the Kit.
The rain rear curtain also comes with oversize side and rear windows for a clear vision during any weather conditions.
- Distinct look
- Waterproof fabric
- Quality stitching
- The rear door fabric is not stable
13. BESTOP 7914635
- Fitted for 2007-2018 Wrangler 2 door
- Diamond sailcloth
- Smaller windows than OEM
- Multi-ply fabric
- Factory original quality specifications
This is a snug fit if you need the best soft top replacement for Jeep Wrangler.
Offering everything a vehicle needs, from shape to functionality and design, this top is the definition of a quality product.
The 28-oz fabric can considerably reduce road noise and enhance insulation while creating a waterproof barrier for any liquid or dust particles. Also, the top is built to respect factory specifications and fit the vehicle perfectly.
Keep in mind that this top is compatible only with the 2007-2018 2-door Jeep Wrangler and that it requires factory hardware for installation.
Moreover, the 30 mil vinyl windows can be customized with an 18% tint for both a modern appearance or cooler interior temperature during the summer.
And now that we mentioned customization, door skins can also be optionally added. They can be attached by simply hooking them to the original door frames.
- Straight forward installation
- Better zipper quality than OEM
- Optional door skins are available
- The fabric can sag in the rain
14. TACTIK JKU1018BDI
- 31% tinted windows with pressed glass
- Multi-layered vinyl-coated polyester & cotton mix
- Compatible with any bow system
- Uses factory hardware
- Precision fit
- Rollable rear cargo window
Tactik is known as the brand that offers the best wallet-friendly option of car accessories without sacrificing quality.
Discover this excellent fit for your Wrangler! It comes with a complete replacement kit, but keep in mind that it requires the factory’s original hardware for installation.
This soft top has incredible specifications. From 31% tinted rear windows and UV-resistant fabric to a simple guide for the easiest setup, it offers everything you need to make your next trip the best one so far.
Bow assembly is not included, but the top is compatible with any bow system, so it shouldn’t be a problem.
Finally, the top offers fold-back capabilities, so a warm summer day can transform into an amazing open-air drive experience.
Available in 2 options, for 2007-2009 JK and 2010-2018 JK, TACTIK JKU1018BDI’ is the best replacement soft top for any JK.
If you’re a Jeep passionate, this is the perfect way to enjoy your adventures to the fullest while also protecting your vehicle!
- The best quality-price ratio
- Sturdy look
- Complete kit
- Long-term durability must be improved
Frequently Asked Questions
Are All Soft Tops The Same?
Soft tops are so different from one another that choosing the best soft top for 4 door Jeep Wrangler can truly become a challenge.
It’s easy to think that all soft tops for Jeep JK are the same, but their compatibility, as well as their design and functionality, are almost unique for each brand.
The only ones that are truly the same are OE design tops created by Bestop for 2997-2006 TK models.
Can a Soft-Top be Changed With a Hardtop and Vice Versa?
Yes, but you shouldn’t place a hard top directly over the soft ones, as each has its specific setup points and designs. What you have to do is remove the soft top first, then place the hardtop.
So, the tops are not interchangeable, but if you remove all the components from one of them and replace the parts, it’s possible to perform this change.
Do Soft Tops Maintain The Interior Warm in Winter?
While it’s easier to imagine that a soft-top would resist the warmth of a summer day, the question becomes more complex when we think about the cold winter days.
Even more, the snow plays is an important factor that can damage the quality of a soft top.
You may be surprised, but soft tops usually resist through the winter with little to no issues.
If your top is properly insulated and its fabric has all the thermic and elastic properties to ensure its function, it will do its job just fine and keep the interior of your Jeep warm even on cold days.
Are Soft Top Jeeps Easy To Break into?
The short answer is no. While hardtops are more durable and offer better protection against such events, soft tops can also be safe if roll bars are added.
Another idea is to get your Jeep Wrangler a lockbox and avoid any stress.
For a Jeep enthusiast, finding the best replacement soft top for your Jeep Wrangler JK means finding a way to protect your vehicle when adventuring in all weather conditions without worrying about any leaks or temperature changes.
Remember all the important aspects and amazing brands presented above and choose the soft top that’s going to make any trip an unforgettable experience!